Tuesday 27 August 2013

Top Most Why Java does not support Operator overloading

Unlike C++, Java doesn't support operator overloading. Java doesn't provide freedom to programmer, to overload the standard arithmetic operators e.g. +, -, * and / etc. If you have worked previously in C++, than you know that, Java has left lot of feature supported in C++ e.g.  Java doesn't support multiple inheritance, no pointers in Java, and no pass by reference in Java. Rarely this question asked in Java interviews, to check how programmer thinks about certain features, which is not supported in Java. Another similar questions is regarding Java being pass by reference, which is mostly appear as, whether Java is pass by value or reference. Though I don't know the real reason behind it, I think following observation make sense on, why Operator overloading is not supported in Java.


1) Simplicity and Cleanliness
Why operator overloading is not supported in JavaSimple and clear design was one of the goals of Java designers. They, just don't want to replicate the language, but wanted to have a clear, truly object oriented language. Adding Operator overloading would have definitely made design more complex than without it, and it might have lead to more complex compiler or slows the JVM ,because it needs to do extra work to identify the actual meaning of operators, and reduce the opportunity to optimize the language by guarantee behavior of operators in Java.

2) Avoid Programming Errors
Java doesn't allow user defined operator overloading, because if you allow programmer to do operator overloading, they will come up with multiple meanings for same operator, which will make the learning curve of any developer hard and things more confusing and messy. Its been observed that, there is increase in programming errors, when language supports operator overloading, which in turn increase e development and delivery time. Since Java and JVM has taken most of developers responsibility,  in memory management by providing garbage collector, it doesn't really make sense to left this feature to pollute the code, and as a loop hole for programming errors.

3) JVM Complexity
From JVM perspective, supporting operator overloading is more difficult, and if the same thing can be achieved, by using method overloading in more intuitive and clean way, it does make sense to not support operator overloading in Java. A complex JVM, may result in slower JVM, than a relatively simpler JVM ,and reduce the opportunity of optimization by taking out guaranteed behavior of operators in Java.

4) Easy Development of Tools
This is an additional benefit of not supporting operator overloading in Java. Omission of operator overloading has kept the language easier to handle and process, which in turn makes it easier to develop the tools, that process the language e.g. IDE or re-factoring tool. Re-factoring tools in Java are far better than C++.

In conclusion many things, which can be achieved by operator overloading, can also be achieved using method overloading using more intuitive and easy way and that might be the reason java designer thought that supporting operator overloading will not be a big benefit for language, but in fact only Java designer can answer real motivation of, why Java doesn't support operator overloading, like some other questions as Why Java doesn't support multiple inheritance or Why String is immutable in Java.

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Labels

Core Java programming core java interview question Core Java Faq's Servlets coding database jsp-servlet spring Java linux unix interview questions java investment bank Web Services Interview investment bank mysql Senior java developer interviews best practices java collection tutorial RMI SQL Eclipse FIX protocol tutorial tibco J2EE groovy java questions SCJP grails java 5 tutorial jdbc beginner error and exception Design Patterns Java Programming Tutorials fundamentals general object oriented programming xml Java Programs Hibernate Examples Flex JAMon Java xml tutorial logging Jsp Struts 2.0 Sybase and SQL Server debugging java interviews performance FIX Protocol interview questions JUnit testing WebSphere date and time tutorial experienced java IO tutorial java concurrency thread Ejb Freshers Papers IT Management Java Exapmle Java Script SQL and database tutorial examples Scwcd ant tutorials concurrency example and tutorial future state homework java changes java threading tricky Agile Business of IT Development JSTL Java JSON tutorial Java multithreading Tutorials PM Scrum data structure and algorithm java puzzles java tips testing tips windows 8 5 way to create Singleton Object Architect Interview Questions and Answers Architecture Architecure Bluetooth server as swing application that searches bluetooth device in 10 meter circle and show all devices. You can send file to any bluetooth device. C Programming CIO Callable Statement in Java Circular dependency of Objects in Java Comparable Example in Collection Custom annotation in Java Developer Interview Divide and rule example in java Drupal Example of Singleton Pattern FIX protocol ForkJoin Example in Java 7 Get data from dynamic table with Java Script Git HTML and JavaScript Health Hello World TCP Client Server Networking Program Hibernate Basics Hibernate Interview Question Answer J2EE Interview Question And Answers J2ME GUI Program JEE Interview QA JMS interview question Java J2EE Hibernate Spring Struts Interview Question Java System Property Java Threads Manager Portlets Provident Fund Read data from any file in same location and give the required result. Reading Properties File in Java Redpoint Rest WebService Client Rest Webservice Test SAL join with ven diagram SCP UNIX COMMAND SSL Singleton Pattern in Java Spring Bean Initialization methods and their order Spring Interview Questions Struts Struts 2.0 Basics Struts 2.0 Design Pattern Submit Html Form With Java Script On The Fly Unix executable For Java Program XOM DOM SAX XP books computers core java; core java; object oriented programming data structure; java investment bank; design pattern dtd duplicate rows in table get browser name with jquery grails podcast inner class java beginners tutorial java cache java networking tutorial java spring java util; java collections; java questions java.java1.5 linked list mailto function with all browser oracle database oracle duplicate rows orm schema social spring mvc questions struts transaction tricks tweet windows xslt